When Truth Becomes a Servant of Activism

What a remarkable study of American scholarship reveals about postmodernism, political certainty, and the Christian understanding of the human person

Introduction — The Surprising Persistence of Truth

A few weeks ago, Princeton professor Robert P. George brought to my attention a remarkable study that raises questions about American higher education—and, more fundamentally, about human nature.

Published by the American Academy of Sciences and Letters, Humanities in Crisis examines the language of 443,543 doctoral dissertations produced at American universities between 1960 and 2025. The researchers wanted to know how the intellectual priorities of the humanities and social sciences had changed.

Some discoveries were unsurprising. The language of identity, power, oppression, and social hierarchy has become increasingly prominent, especially in fields influenced by poststructuralist1Poststructuralism rejects authorial intention as interpretive authority, treating texts instead as cultural composites where meaning resides with the reader rather than the author. Central to deconstructionist strategy is the concept of “différance”—the idea that language operates through endless difference and deferral, making any single fixed interpretation impossible. Power analysis also features prominently, particularly in recognizing how institutions use discourse to impose particular perspectives while masking their exercise of influence. and postcolonial2Postcolonialism investigates how colonization has shaped societies, examines the power structures embedded in colonial knowledge systems, and amplifies the perspectives of those marginalized by cultural domination. theories. The study also found that Activism was increasingly viewed in a positive light—more so than any of the other terms the researchers examined.

But as I was reading through this study, another finding caught my attention.

Despite these intellectual changes, the language of truth has remained remarkably resilient. Scholars still employ the vocabulary of evidence, reason, and factual inquiry, while Truth itself retains consistently positive associations.

Now, there’s something intriguing about that.

Many contemporary frameworks emphasize how our understanding of reality is shaped by language, culture, identity, and relations of power. Yet scholars employing these frameworks—and activists who draw upon them—often express extraordinary confidence in their judgments about injustice and how society ought to be reconstructed.

Is there a philosophical tension here? Perhaps even a contradiction?

And what happens when our desire to change the world becomes more powerful than our willingness to discover what is true about it?

From the Pursuit of Truth to the Analysis of Power

For centuries, the humanities have wrestled with great questions of human existence. What is true? What is good? What is beautiful? What can history teach us about human nature, and what can literature reveal about the human condition?

These questions haven’t disappeared. But the study documents a striking shift in how many scholars approach them.

Beginning in the late 1980s, references to power, domination, oppression, hierarchy, and resistance increased dramatically, particularly in literature and language departments. During the 1990s, power-related vocabulary overtook both aesthetics and evaluation in those fields.

Meanwhile, the language of identity—race, gender, intersectionality, privilege, and related concepts—was growing even faster. The researchers estimate annual growth of approximately 5–8 percent in identity-related vocabulary in their statistical models. Especially pronounced changes appeared in literature, interdisciplinary programs, and certain social sciences.

These patterns reflect, at least in part, the growing influence of poststructuralist,3Poststructuralism rejects authorial intention as interpretive authority, treating texts instead as cultural composites where meaning resides with the reader rather than the author. Central to deconstructionist strategy is the concept of “différance”—the idea that language operates through endless difference and deferral, making any single fixed interpretation impossible. Power analysis also features prominently, particularly in recognizing how institutions use discourse to impose particular perspectives while masking their exercise of influence. postcolonial,4Postcolonialism investigates how colonization has shaped societies, examines the power structures embedded in colonial knowledge systems, and amplifies the perspectives of those marginalized by cultural domination. and critical-theory approaches. Human experience is increasingly examined through relationships between identity and power: who possesses it, who is excluded from it, and how institutions perpetuate hierarchies.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with studying power or exposing injustice. Human history supplies abundant evidence of both.

But what happens when one analytical framework becomes so dominant that it crowds out other ways of understanding human experience?

Is literature primarily an expression of artistic imagination and an exploration of the human condition—or principally a reflection of prevailing power structures? Is history an attempt to understand the past in all its complexity—or chiefly a search for patterns of domination and oppression?

These need not be mutually exclusive inquiries. But their relative emphasis matters.

And here we encounter the study’s most surprising finding: through all these changes, the vocabulary of truth has stubbornly persisted.

The Postmodern Paradox: Certain That Certainty Is Impossible?

Here is where things get particularly interesting.

Many influential academic frameworks emphasize the extent to which knowledge is shaped by language, culture, and social circumstances. Some go further, questioning whether we can attain objective truths independent of those influences.

Yet scholars employing these frameworks—and activists drawing upon them—can appear remarkably certain about their own conclusions. They confidently identify oppressive structures, pronounce judgments about injustice, and prescribe sweeping changes to society.

But on what grounds?

There is an enormous difference between saying that our understanding of reality is influenced by our circumstances and saying that truth itself is merely a product of those circumstances.

The first proposition contains genuine insight. None of us approaches the world without assumptions and cultural influences. The second is far more problematic.

Consider the genetic fallacy: judging an argument true or false simply because of where it comes from.

Suppose someone dismisses an argument about justice because it emerges from a Western, Christian, or capitalist tradition. That tells us something about the argument’s ancestry. It tells us nothing, by itself, about whether the argument is true.

The same principle applies to beliefs emerging from progressive or marginalized communities. Their origins neither establish nor invalidate their truth. Arguments must be evaluated on their merits, not merely their pedigree.

The problem becomes sharper when we move from truth to morality.

To declare a social arrangement unjust is to make a moral judgment. But according to what standard? If justice itself is merely a product of social conditioning and power relations, why should one group’s conception of justice be morally superior to another’s?

When truth and morality are reduced to expressions of power, while universal judgments about injustice are advanced with absolute confidence, a serious philosophical tension emerges.

And that tension becomes especially consequential when an intellectual framework becomes a program not merely for understanding society, but for remaking it.

When Scholarship Becomes a Program for Social Transformation

That sentiment captures something important about contemporary activism: understanding society is not enough. Society must be transformed.

Consider the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), an organization I’ve examined extensively in earlier posts. Its published program illustrates how a comprehensive theory of social injustice can become a blueprint for reconstructing political and economic life.

The DSA’s 2026 program, Workers Deserve More, calls for public ownership of the largest corporations and essential industries, abolition of the Senate, and replacement of the presidency and Supreme Court with institutions chosen by and subordinate to Congress. It also identifies the eventual abolition of police and prisons as an objective.

These are not modest adjustments to existing arrangements. The program envisions rebuilding society on fundamentally different foundations.

Its authors describe capitalism and existing political institutions, (contrary to empirical evidence) as systems that reproduce exploitation and inequality. Their proposed remedy is a democratic socialist society organized around working-class power.

Marxism and postmodernism, of course, are not identical philosophies. Marxism makes substantial claims about objective economic and historical reality, whereas certain postmodern theories question the foundations of such claims. Still, strands of contemporary activism combine Marxist class analysis with critical theories emphasizing race, gender, identity, and power.

And here the philosophical question becomes intensely practical.

What happens when a framework becomes so comprehensive that disagreement is interpreted mainly as evidence of privilege, oppression, or class interest? What happens when an objection is dismissed because of the supposed social position of the person making it, rather than answered on its merits?

The genetic fallacy can become a political habit.

I don’t doubt that many activists sincerely wish to remedy injustice. Nor are existing institutions beyond criticism. But sincerity is not wisdom, and identifying a genuine problem does not mean we fully understand its causes or possess a workable remedy.

The desire to make society more just is commendable. But justice requires more than identifying oppressors and redistributing power. It requires a truthful understanding of human beings themselves.

A Christian Anthropology: Why Truth Cannot Be Abolished

Christianity begins with a profoundly different understanding of the human person.

The world is not simply raw material awaiting reconstruction according to our preferred ideological vision. It is God’s Good Creation, possessing an intelligible order that precedes us. Nor are human beings infinitely malleable creatures whose nature can be endlessly redefined by changing social circumstances. We are embodied beings, created in the image of God as male and female, endowed with reason, moral responsibility, and the capacity to recognize truth and goodness.

This understanding resonates with the natural-law tradition, from Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas to contemporary philosophers such as Robert P. George.

George, together with philosopher Patrick Lee, has defended the equal and inherent dignity of human beings on the basis of our rational nature: our fundamental capacities for understanding, deliberation, and free choice. In the natural-law account, genuine human goods and moral obligations are accessible to reason, not exclusively to those who accept Christian revelation.

This matters enormously. Christians need not claim that only Christians can recognize injustice or discover moral truth. We can argue about what is good and just because human reason, however imperfectly exercised, is capable of apprehending a reality neither society nor government invents.

But Christianity adds another indispensable consideration: the Fall.

We are capable of knowing what is good, yet remarkably adept at deceiving ourselves. Pride, resentment, self-interest, and the desire for power can corrupt even our noblest intentions. We can sincerely believe we’re pursuing justice while remaining blind to the injustices we perpetuate.

And this isn’t merely a progressive or socialist problem. Conservatives and Christians face precisely the same temptations.

That recognition ought to cultivate humility, particularly when we propose sweeping changes to institutions developed across generations.

It also exposes a weakness in political theories that locate the principal source of human suffering in oppressive structures. Institutions certainly can be unjust, and Christians have compelling reasons to reform them. But the problem runs deeper. Human beings are not merely victims of defective institutions. We are moral agents whose disordered desires also create and sustain injustice.

Change the institutions, and you may improve society. But you will not thereby eliminate greed, envy, pride, or the appetite for domination.

The Christian understanding of humanity is therefore both hopeful and realistic. We possess genuine capacities for reason, goodness, and moral progress. But we are neither omniscient nor morally incorruptible.

Any political movement that forgets either side of that truth risks misunderstanding both the problems it seeks to remedy and the people it proposes to help.

Justice Without Utopianism: Activism Accountable to Truth

None of this means that Christians should retreat from public life or remain indifferent to injustice. Quite the contrary.

The biblical prophets condemned exploitation and corruption. Christians played important roles in abolitionism, the struggle for civil rights, and countless efforts to relieve suffering. The pursuit of justice is not optional for those who take Christian moral teaching seriously.

But there is a difference between seeking justice and assuming that our preferred political arrangements will necessarily produce it.

The late Catholic philosopher Michael Novak offers a valuable insight here. In The Spirit of Democratic Capitalism, he emphasized three distinct but interdependent spheres: democratic political institutions, a free economy, and an independent moral-cultural order.

None can substitute for the others. Political power cannot manufacture virtue; economic prosperity cannot guarantee moral wisdom; even sound constitutional arrangements depend on citizens capable of exercising freedom responsibly.

This challenges political visions that locate the solution to human suffering principally in comprehensive institutional restructuring.

And it raises questions we should ask of every proposed reform. Does it accurately identify the problem? Does it account for human motivation, limits on knowledge, and unintended consequences? Does it preserve the dignity, freedom, and responsibility of the people it intends to help?

These are not excuses for inaction. They are requirements of responsible moral action.

The danger of ideological activism is not necessarily that its adherents care too much about justice. It is that certainty can make them insufficiently attentive to reality—especially facts that complicate their preferred solutions.

A Christian pursuit of justice must be governed by truth, tempered by humility, and informed by a realistic understanding of human nature.

Conclusion — Truth Before Transformation

The authors of Humanities in Crisis set out to examine sixty-five years of American scholarship. Among their most intriguing discoveries was something that had stubbornly endured: even as the language of identity and power expanded, the language of truth persisted.

But that finding raises the question: Can we meaningfully argue for justice without believing that some judgments are true and others false?

Christianity reminds us that reality is not ours to invent. We inhabit God’s Good Creation, possess the capacity to understand it, and bear responsibility for acting justly within it. Yet we are also fallen creatures, remarkably capable of confusing our convictions with wisdom and our ambitions with virtue.

The answer is not to abandon efforts to change the world. It is to recognize that even our noblest aspirations must be accountable to something greater than our own ideological certainty.

Truth must judge our activism. Activism must never become the judge of truth.


+++

When Telling a Child the Truth Becomes Suspect

Helen Joyce, the UK’s Conversion Practices Bill, and the problem of expressive individualism

Helen Joyce is one of the sharpest thinkers I’ve encountered on the subject of sex and contemporary identity politics. She has a remarkable ability to cut through complicated arguments and expose assumptions that others seem reluctant to question.

The accompanying three-minute video below illustrates that ability beautifully.

On October 29, 2026, Joyce, representing the organization Sex Matters, testified before a joint committee of the British Parliament examining the government’s proposed Conversion Practices Bill.

Her testimony raises a question that ought to concern parents, clergy, therapists, and anyone who values freedom of conscience:

When did telling a child the truth become something the government might regard as abusive?

An Eleven-Year-Old Girl and Her Mother

Joyce asks the committee to consider an autistic eleven-year-old girl who identifies as non-binary. The child sincerely believes she is neither male nor female.

Her mother knows otherwise.

She knows her daughter is female, that she will undergo female puberty, and that her daughter’s feelings about her identity cannot alter those biological realities.

The mother may feel obligated to explain these things, even when doing so causes distress.

Joyce makes the essential observation about the daughter:

“Her declaration, her words don’t make reality.”

Now suppose the mother restricts access to certain websites or friendships she believes are reinforcing her daughter’s confusion. The child becomes anxious, perhaps even refuses to attend school.

Has the mother engaged in abusive behavior? Or has she exercised ordinary parental judgment in a difficult situation?

Joyce’s concern is that the proposed legislation does not adequately distinguish between the two.

She offers another illustration. If a husband confiscates his wife’s telephone to isolate her from friends and family, that would constitute coercive control.

But if a mother temporarily confiscates her eleven-year-old daughter’s telephone to protect her from harmful influences, that is an entirely different matter.

Surely our laws must recognize the distinction.

What the Proposed Law Actually Says

The British government’s draft Conversion Practices Bill, published June 25, 2026, seeks to prohibit abusive efforts to change someone’s sexual orientation or transgender identity.

Protecting people from violence, intimidation, and genuine psychological abuse is an entirely legitimate objective.

But the legislation raises questions about what constitutes abuse.

Clause 1 includes conduct intended to cause someone to have, not have, or believe they have or do not have a particular sexual orientation or transgender identity.

In determining whether conduct is abusive, the bill directs attention to factors including controlling behavior and psychological or emotional pressure.

Clause 2 requires serious physical or mental harm, or serious alarm or distress substantially affecting everyday activities. The maximum criminal penalty is five years’ imprisonment.

The government insists that ordinary parenting, religious expression, and legitimate conversations would remain protected.

Nevertheless, the draft contains no explicit general exemption for parents exercising ordinary parental responsibilities. Nor does it provide an equivalent express protection for pastoral guidance.

And that is the concern Joyce and other critics are raising.

The proposed legislation also permits preventive protection orders, potentially bringing disputed conduct under judicial scrutiny without a prior criminal conviction.

The question is not whether genuinely abusive practices should be prohibited.

The question is whether the law distinguishes adequately between abuse and the legitimate responsibilities of parents, counselors, and religious leaders.

Children Need Guidance, Not Merely Affirmation

Children are not miniature adults.

We do not ordinarily treat their emerging preferences, convictions, or self-understandings as beyond question.

A child may sincerely believe something that is mistaken. A loving parent may be obliged to correct that belief, even when the correction is unwelcome.

This is particularly important when children experience distress concerning their developing bodies.

Therapists should be free to explore the possible sources of that distress without being required to reach a predetermined conclusion.

That means rejecting coercive attempts to force a particular identity upon someone. But it also means rejecting the opposite assumption that every declared identity must automatically be affirmed.

Genuine exploratory therapy should be free to explore.

The same principle matters in pastoral care. A priest or pastor should be able to discuss traditional Christian teachings about sexuality with someone voluntarily seeking that counsel, without unnecessary fear that the conversation itself will attract legal suspicion.

Compassion and honest disagreement are not mutually exclusive.

The Deeper Problem: Expressive Individualism

There is a larger philosophical issue beneath this controversy.

In The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self, Christian historian Carl Trueman examines what he calls expressive individualism.

The concept, associated particularly with philosopher Charles Taylor, describes the modern conviction that our deepest identity is discovered within our psychological lives—our feelings, desires, and subjective experiences—and that authentic living requires outward expression of that inner identity.

In this worldview, personal authenticity becomes a central measure of human flourishing.

But consider the implications.

If my deepest feelings determine who I am, then someone who questions my self-understanding may appear to be doing more than disagreeing with me.

They may appear to be denying my very identity.

And if affirmation becomes a moral obligation, disagreement can be interpreted as psychological injury.

This helps explain why an ordinary parental conversation about biological sex can become so contentious.

What one person regards as a loving acknowledgment of reality, another may interpret as an attack upon personal identity.

We have moved from the proposition that people deserve dignity and respect to the untenable proposition that respecting someone necessarily requires affirming that person’s subjective understanding of reality.

Those are not the same thing.

The Christian Understanding of the Human Person

Christianity offers a fundamentally different understanding of human identity.

We are not self-created beings whose bodies are incidental to our deepest selves.

We are embodied creatures, made in the image of God—male and female, according to Genesis 1:27, and Jesus (Matthew 19:4).

The body is not an inconvenient biological shell surrounding the supposedly authentic person within.

Our bodies belong to who we are.

Indeed, the Christian story places extraordinary importance upon embodiment: Creation, the Incarnation, Christ’s bodily resurrection and ascension, and the promised resurrection of our own bodies.

This does not mean dismissing psychological suffering. Quite the contrary. Christians are called to respond with patience, compassion, and love.

But compassion does not require treating subjective experience as the final authority on reality.

And love sometimes requires telling someone something they do not want to hear.

Protecting Children Without Criminalizing Care

The proposed British legislation remains under parliamentary scrutiny. The joint committee is scheduled to report by January 22, 2027. Its final language and legal consequences remain uncertain.

That makes Joyce’s testimony especially timely. After having followed Joyce for many years now, (see here, here, here, & here), I unhesitatingly say; if she is concerned, I’m concerned.

A civilized society must protect vulnerable people from genuine abuse. But it must also preserve the freedom of parents to parent, therapists to investigate, and religious leaders to offer counsel consistent with their convictions.

None of those freedoms licenses cruelty or coercion.

But neither should they become casualties of legislation that fails to distinguish responsible guidance from abusive conduct.

Helen Joyce has identified a question that reaches well beyond Britain.

When a child’s subjective identity conflicts with biological reality, will parents and professionals remain free to discuss that conflict honestly and compassionately?

Or will the fear of being accused of abuse determine what they are permitted to say?

I encourage you to watch her three-minute testimony and consider what is at stake.



+++

Getting People Off the Streets Is Compassion, Too

For all “X” videos, click on the aqua circle to show video.

I have no idea whether Steve Hilton, the Republican candidate for governor of California, is a Christian. And frankly, for purposes of what I want to say here, it doesn’t matter very much.

What interests me is his recently released proposal for dealing with California’s homelessness crisis, because I think it illustrates something Christians must think about more carefully: What does compassion actually require?

Hilton calls his proposal “Off the Streets and Back on Track.” The basic idea is remarkably straightforward. California would build a network of Homeless Recovery Centers where people currently living on streets, sidewalks, parks, and encampments could receive shelter, food, showers, medical attention, addiction treatment, psychiatric care, job training, and help moving into permanent housing.

Families, women, veterans, and elderly residents would have separate secure accommodations. People struggling with drug addiction would be offered treatment. Those suffering from serious mental illness would receive appropriate psychiatric care. Those capable of working would be connected with community colleges, apprenticeship programs, employers, and job training. Caseworkers would help individuals move toward stable housing and continue providing care when necessary.

And then comes the other half of the proposal—the half that will undoubtedly make some people uncomfortable.

The encampments would be cleared.

Public camping laws would once again be enforced. If a safe and appropriate place is available, declining that help would not confer a permanent right to occupy a sidewalk, public park, or street.

I find that combination—not one half without the other—very important.

Compassion and Order Are Not Enemies

For years now, I have been arguing with some of my progressive Christian friends about what we mean when we use words like compassion, justice, and care for the poor.

Christians are unquestionably commanded to care for the suffering.

There is no wiggle room there.

The widow, the orphan, the poor, the stranger, the sick, the prisoner, the abandoned—Scripture repeatedly directs our attention toward people who are vulnerable. A Christianity that simply walks past suffering and says, “Not my problem,” is difficult to reconcile with Jesus.


Credit : Wikipedia I Wallace Collection
Le Bon Samaritain, Rembrandt, 1632-1633.

But something else does not follow from that.

The Bible does not hand us a state budget.

It does not specify the proper size of Medicaid, the correct marginal tax rate, how much California should spend on homelessness, whether housing should come before addiction treatment, or under what circumstances someone suffering from serious mental illness should be compelled to receive care.

Those are questions of prudence.

Compassion tells us that the person sleeping beneath an overpass matters. Prudence asks: What will actually help him?

And those are not always the same question.

R. R. Reno recently made a related point while discussing immigration. Pastoral language about welcoming or accompanying people may express a genuine Christian moral concern, but it does not by itself tell governing authorities where limits should be drawn or how competing obligations should be balanced. Governments still have to govern.

The same principle applies here.

Is Leaving Someone in a Tent Compassionate?

Consider the strange situation we have created.

A man is living beneath a tarp. He may be addicted to fentanyl. He may suffer from schizophrenia. He hasn’t bathed in weeks. He is vulnerable to assault, disease, exploitation, overdose, heat, cold, and predatory drug dealers.

One “enlightened” response amounts to:

Here is a clean needle. Here is some food. Here is a blanket. We will respect your autonomy. Good luck.

Is that compassion or abandonment dressed in compassionate language?

Hilton’s proposal takes a different approach. Get the person inside. Feed him. Give him a bed and a shower. Find out what is wrong. Treat the addiction. Treat the mental illness. Help him acquire skills. Help him find employment if he is capable of it. Help him eventually find stable housing.

And, yes, establish some expectations along the way.

That strikes me as a much richer understanding of human dignity.

Human beings possess dignity precisely because they are more than bundles of immediate desires. We are embodied creatures capable of relationships, responsibility, work, recovery, community, and—in Christian terms—redemption.

Sometimes love comforts.

Sometimes love intervenes.

Often it does both.

Twenty-Four Billion Dollars Should Buy Accountability

There is another part of Hilton’s proposal that connects directly with something I have been writing about for months: government spending is not the same thing as compassion.

California allocated nearly $24 billion to homelessness and housing between fiscal years 2018–19 and 2022–23. That number does not come from a partisan campaign advertisement. It appears in the California State Auditor’s own report.

And what did the auditor find?

Not that every program was worthless. In fact, two of the five programs examined appeared to be cost-effective.

But the auditors could not adequately evaluate three of the five because California had not collected sufficient outcome data. The state had also failed to consistently track costs and results across its homelessness efforts.

Think about that.

Billions upon billions of dollars—and government often could not confidently tell taxpayers what was working.

I’ve made this point before: Christian stewardship should care about that too.

If I give $1,000 to a charity claiming to feed hungry children and discover that nobody is checking whether children are actually being fed, asking questions about the money does not demonstrate my lack of compassion.

It demonstrates stewardship.

Why should $24 billion of taxpayers’ money be morally different?

The proper measure cannot simply be: How much did we spend?

The question is: Did suffering decrease? Did people recover? Did they remain housed? Did addicts become sober? Did mentally ill people receive treatment? Did families get back on their feet?

Hilton proposes auditing homelessness spending, publishing costs and outcomes, and redirecting money away from programs that repeatedly fail toward treatment and recovery programs that produce measurable results.

That ought not be a left-wing or right-wing principle.

It is common sense.

Neither Cruelty Nor Sentimentality

The fundamental principle: We do not have to choose between abandoning people on the streets and abandoning public order.

A civilized society should be capable of saying two things simultaneously.

You may not live indefinitely on this sidewalk.

And:

We are not going to abandon you.

Come inside.

Here is a bed.

Here is food.

Here is medical care.

Here is addiction treatment.

Here is psychiatric treatment.

Here is job training.

Here is someone whose job is to help you get back on your feet.

But no, we are not going to pretend that living in a tent while addicted, mentally ill, sick, exploited, and isolated represents some higher form of human autonomy that the rest of society is morally obligated to preserve.

That isn’t compassion.

There is a distinctly Christian insight here.

Christian love never means simply affirming another human being exactly where he happens to be and then walking away. We meet people where they are because they bear the image of God.

But we love them too much to insist that they remain there.

For California’s homeless, perhaps genuine compassion begins with something as concrete as this:

Come in off the street. Let’s help you get your life back.


I follow this Citizen Journalist on X. If you have an X account, and you are interested in this issue, you should follow as well.

Addendum: A Role for Private Generosity

One final thought. I’m confident that many of the tech titans who call San Francisco and Silicon Valley home would be willing to make substantial charitable contributions toward solving this crisis—if they had good reason to believe their money would actually make a difference.

But there’s another economic reality California’s political leadership would be wise to consider. Wealthy individuals and businesses can relocate, and California’s high taxes and recurring proposals for additional wealth taxes create incentives for them to do precisely that.

This is something advocates of wealth taxes, including those aligned with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), don’t understand. Wealth today is not primarily land, as it was centuries ago. Much of it consists of financial assets, intellectual property, business ownership, and highly mobile capital. People can move, companies can relocate, and investment can flow elsewhere. Not without complications, of course, but much more readily than a landed estate could move in the eighteenth century.

And when wealthy entrepreneurs leave, California risks losing more than tax revenue. It can also lose jobs, investment, civic leadership, and substantial philanthropic resources.

California still has extraordinary private wealth and philanthropic potential. But government policies that discourage wealth creation or encourage its departure also diminish the very resources available to address problems like homelessness.

Imagine what might happen if government, private philanthropy, churches, and charitable organizations worked together around a serious, transparent, results-oriented plan. Not simply managing homelessness, but actually helping people escape it.

Accountability doesn’t discourage generosity. It gives generosity a reason to flourish. And sound economic policy helps preserve the wealth that makes such generosity possible.

+++

We Don’t Have To Live Like This