I’ve had this graphic in my back pocket for a while because it helps put something into perspective that gets lost in our immigration discussions: just how extraordinary America’s record of welcoming immigrants really is.
And before you dismiss it as another provocative blog post <grin>, the numbers in the lower chart come directly from the United Nations, not some conservative think tank.
According to the UN’s International Migrant Stock 2024 estimates, approximately 304 million people worldwide were living outside their countries of birth. Of those, 52.4 million lived in the United States. That’s 17.2% of all international migrants—roughly one out of every six on the planet!
Germany, in second place, had 16.8 million. Saudi Arabia had 13.7 million, and the United Kingdom 11.8 million.
In other words, America hosted more than three times as many immigrants as any other country. Indeed, our total exceeded the next four countries combined!
That’s remarkable. And I think it deserves acknowledgment whenever America is portrayed by Leftists as unusually hostile to immigrants.
To be clear, these figures include naturalized citizens, legal residents, and those here unlawfully. They don’t mean 52 million people crossed our border illegally or that they all arrived recently. And some countries have a higher proportion of immigrants relative to their populations. But in absolute numbers, nothing compares to the United States.
There’s also an interesting employment dimension.
The Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), analyzing Bureau of Labor Statistics household survey data, reported that between January 2020 and January 2025, 88% of net employment growth went to foreign-born workers—roughly 4.7 million additional employed immigrants compared with approximately 645,000 additional employed native-born Americans.
Now, that statistic describes a particular five-year period, beginning just before the pandemic. It doesn’t prove immigrants “stole” jobs from Americans. But surely it raises legitimate questions about immigration levels, labor markets, wages, and opportunities for Americans already struggling to find stable employment.
And then there’s the question of welfare and public resources.
A separate CIS study, using Census Bureau data, found that 53% of immigrant-headed households received at least one major welfare benefit, compared with 37% of households headed by native-born Americans. That’s a substantial difference.
Another CIS analysis, examining noncitizen-headed households by country of origin, reported particularly high rates of welfare participation or income-based eligibility for refundable tax credits among households from Guatemala (77%) and Mexico (67%).
Now, an important qualification: these are household statistics, not claims that every individual in those households personally receives welfare. Benefits may go to American-born children, for example.
But the substantial participation rates certainly raise legitimate questions about public spending, the kinds of immigration we should encourage, and whether our present policies are economically sustainable.
And none of this diminishes the larger point.
America has demonstrated an extraordinary willingness to welcome immigrants.
Yet, listening to some progressive voices, you would think we’re a nation characterized primarily by hostility toward foreigners, rather than one that has welcomed more immigrants than any other country on earth.
This brings me back to something I’ve raised in our previous posts about Christian ethics and immigration.
I don’t believe that Christian compassion for the stranger requires us to abandon the distinction between legal and illegal immigration, or pretend that borders, public resources, assimilation, and obligations to our fellow citizens are morally irrelevant.
A nation can welcome immigrants generously while insisting on lawful entry, enforcing immigration laws, and asking whether the pace and scale of immigration are sustainable.
Indeed, I would argue that an orderly immigration system is essential if our generosity is to remain sustainable over the long term.
Christian charity is not the same thing as unlimited public policy commitments. Governments have responsibilities that extend beyond welcoming newcomers, including preserving the rule of law and protecting the welfare of those already living within their borders.
So here’s my question: Given these extraordinary numbers, is it really fair to suggest that Americans who want meaningful immigration limits, enforcement of our laws, and accountability for public spending are somehow lacking in Christian compassion?
I don’t think so.
And I think these facts deserve considerably more attention than they ordinarily receive in our political discussions.
Sources: United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs,
Pew Research Center, Center for Immigration Studies (1) and Center for Immigration Studies (2).
+++
