America, Immigration, and a Little Perspective


I’ve had this graphic in my back pocket for a while because it helps put something into perspective that gets lost in our immigration discussions: just how extraordinary America’s record of welcoming immigrants really is.

And before you dismiss it as another provocative blog post <grin>, the numbers in the lower chart come directly from the United Nations, not some conservative think tank.

According to the UN’s International Migrant Stock 2024 estimates, approximately 304 million people worldwide were living outside their countries of birth. Of those, 52.4 million lived in the United States. That’s 17.2% of all international migrants—roughly one out of every six on the planet!

Germany, in second place, had 16.8 million. Saudi Arabia had 13.7 million, and the United Kingdom 11.8 million.

That’s remarkable. And I think it deserves acknowledgment whenever America is portrayed by Leftists as unusually hostile to immigrants.

To be clear, these figures include naturalized citizens, legal residents, and those here unlawfully. They don’t mean 52 million people crossed our border illegally or that they all arrived recently. And some countries have a higher proportion of immigrants relative to their populations. But in absolute numbers, nothing compares to the United States.


There’s also an interesting employment dimension.

The Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), analyzing Bureau of Labor Statistics household survey data, reported that between January 2020 and January 2025, 88% of net employment growth went to foreign-born workers—roughly 4.7 million additional employed immigrants compared with approximately 645,000 additional employed native-born Americans.

Now, that statistic describes a particular five-year period, beginning just before the pandemic. It doesn’t prove immigrants “stole” jobs from Americans. But surely it raises legitimate questions about immigration levels, labor markets, wages, and opportunities for Americans already struggling to find stable employment.


And then there’s the question of welfare and public resources.

A separate CIS study, using Census Bureau data, found that 53% of immigrant-headed households received at least one major welfare benefit, compared with 37% of households headed by native-born Americans. That’s a substantial difference.

Another CIS analysis, examining noncitizen-headed households by country of origin, reported particularly high rates of welfare participation or income-based eligibility for refundable tax credits among households from Guatemala (77%) and Mexico (67%).

Now, an important qualification: these are household statistics, not claims that every individual in those households personally receives welfare. Benefits may go to American-born children, for example.

But the substantial participation rates certainly raise legitimate questions about public spending, the kinds of immigration we should encourage, and whether our present policies are economically sustainable.

And none of this diminishes the larger point.

America has demonstrated an extraordinary willingness to welcome immigrants.

This brings me back to something I’ve raised in our previous posts about Christian ethics and immigration.

I don’t believe that Christian compassion for the stranger requires us to abandon the distinction between legal and illegal immigration, or pretend that borders, public resources, assimilation, and obligations to our fellow citizens are morally irrelevant.

A nation can welcome immigrants generously while insisting on lawful entry, enforcing immigration laws, and asking whether the pace and scale of immigration are sustainable.

Indeed, I would argue that an orderly immigration system is essential if our generosity is to remain sustainable over the long term.

Christian charity is not the same thing as unlimited public policy commitments. Governments have responsibilities that extend beyond welcoming newcomers, including preserving the rule of law and protecting the welfare of those already living within their borders.

So here’s my question: Given these extraordinary numbers, is it really fair to suggest that Americans who want meaningful immigration limits, enforcement of our laws, and accountability for public spending are somehow lacking in Christian compassion?

I don’t think so.

And I think these facts deserve considerably more attention than they ordinarily receive in our political discussions.

Sources: United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs,
Pew Research Center, Center for Immigration Studies (1) and Center for Immigration Studies (2).

+++

Politics with a Proof Text

A Thought Experiment

At this point, I would like to ask my progressive Christian friends a few questions.

Not rhetorical questions, actually.

I sincerely want to know where they draw the line.

Suppose we could accurately identify every noncitizen who is unlawfully present in the United States.

Would it be morally permissible for a Christian to support the removal of those who have committed serious crimes?

Surely the answer must be yes.

And if such a person is already sitting in a county jail, is it really more Christian for local authorities to refuse cooperation with ICE—thereby requiring federal agents later to locate that person somewhere in the community?

Why?

Would it not be more humane, safer, and more orderly for immigration authorities to take custody at the jail once the criminal case permits it?

Would supporting that policy make me insufficiently concerned about “the stranger”?

I don’t see how.

Now suppose the person being removed has a wife and children.

Family separation raises serious moral concerns. But does that make removal morally impermissible? What if assistance is provided so the family can remain together by returning together?

Would Christians still be prohibited from supporting removal?

If so, why?

Let’s go further.

What about a noncitizen who entered unlawfully, has no valid claim to remain, and openly rejects the laws and civic obligations of the country whose hospitality he is demanding?

Does “love the stranger” require that he remain indefinitely?

Again: why?

And here I want to make an important distinction.

I am not arguing that government should deport people merely because they criticize America, wave a Mexican flag at a protest, advocate socialism, practice Islam, or hold political opinions I dislike.

My question is more fundamental:

Does Christian hospitality impose no reciprocal obligation upon the person receiving that hospitality?

Does the stranger have duties as well as rights?

Must he obey the laws?

May the host country expect him to accommodate himself to its civic order?

May it refuse admission—or terminate permission to remain—when the conditions of its lawful immigration system have not been satisfied?

And may the state consider national security, public safety, capacity for assimilation, and the welfare of its existing citizens when deciding whom to admit?

If the answer to all of those questions is still, “No, Christian love requires us to let them remain,” then I think the biblical proof-texting needs to be examined very carefully.

Ancient Israel certainly did not understand “love the stranger” to mean that the stranger entered a community without obligations.

The ger (stranger) was protected.

He was not to be exploited or oppressed.

He was to receive justice.

But he also lived within an ordered community governed by laws that applied to him as well as to the native-born.

That part of the biblical picture tends to disappear when “welcome the stranger” is lifted out of its literary and historical context and dropped directly into a twenty-first-century immigration debate.

So here is the question I really want my progressive Christian friends to answer:

Is there any immigration restriction or deportation policy that you would regard as morally legitimate?

If the answer is yes, then good. We are no longer debating whether Christians may enforce immigration laws. We are debating which laws, under what circumstances, enforced how, and with what degree of mercy and prudence.

That is a political and prudential argument.

Scripture informs it.

Scripture constrains it.

Scripture certainly forbids cruelty and injustice.

But Scripture does not settle every policy question simply by giving us the phrase “love the stranger.”

And if the answer is no—if practically every meaningful attempt to exclude, remove, or restrict unlawful immigration is condemned as unchristian—then I begin to suspect that something other than exegesis is doing much of the work.

Perhaps a political philosophy is being smuggled into the biblical text and then handed back to us as though it were simply “what Jesus requires.”

That is precisely the kind of proof-texting Christians of every political persuasion should resist.

The Political Philosophy Beneath the Proof Text

I suspect there is sometimes another political philosophy operating beneath this biblical argument—one that should be brought into the open and debated on its own merits.

It goes roughly like this:

The wealthy nations of the “Global North”—the old “First World”—became wealthy in significant measure through colonialism, slavery, exploitation, extraction, and domination of the poorer nations of the “Global South” or “Majority World.”

Therefore, today’s enormous disparities in wealth are not merely differences in economic development. They are, at least in significant measure, the accumulated consequences of historical injustice.

And from that premise follows a reparative obligation.

Wealthy Western nations are therefore expected to redistribute wealth, accept more migrants from poorer nations, relax immigration restrictions, and in some versions of the argument treat migration itself as a form of reparation for colonialism.

That line of reasoning is not something I am inventing. Serious contemporary political theorists explicitly argue for “migration as reparation.”

Now, that is a political and historical argument worth having.

But notice what has happened.

We have moved a very long way from:

“You shall love the stranger.”

We are now talking about colonial guilt, global redistribution, reparations, and the moral legitimacy of national borders.

Those are not the same argument.

And that is precisely why I object when the entire package is presented to Christians as though it simply falls out of a few biblical verses about “the stranger.”

It doesn’t.

If someone wants to argue that the modern West owes the developing world reparations because its prosperity was produced principally through exploitation, make that historical case.

If someone wants to argue that present-day Americans inherit a moral debt for the acts of previous empires or generations, make that philosophical case.

If someone wants to argue that immigration should function as a mechanism of global wealth redistribution, make that economic case.

But don’t simply quote Leviticus and imply that Christians who reject those conclusions have somehow rejected Scripture.

That is exactly the move I am objecting to.

And I reject much of the underlying premise anyway.

The prosperity of the modern West cannot plausibly be reduced to colonial plunder.

Institutions matter.

The rule of law matters.

Property rights matter.

Scientific and technological development matter.

Markets matter.

Political stability, education, cultural habits, and human capital matter.

History certainly includes exploitation, conquest, slavery, and genuine injustices for which moral reckoning may be necessary.

But the simplistic morality play in which the rich world became rich primarily because it stole from the poor world—and therefore now owes the poor world access to its borders and accumulated wealth—is an historical and economic thesis, not a biblical commandment.

And that is the crucial distinction.

Once again, the danger is that a modern political ideology gets smuggled into the biblical text and then emerges wearing a clerical collar.

That is not exegesis.

That is politics with a proof text.

+++

Borders and Brotherhood: A Catholic Look at Immigration and the Ordo Amoris


In our polarized moment, immigration policy is one of those topics that easily divides sincere believers. Some Christians—often from a more progressive persuasion—emphasize our Gospel duty to welcome the stranger. Others, more traditionally minded, stress the importance of preserving cultural integrity, the rule of law, and the common good of the political community. Both instincts, in truth, have a place within the Christian moral tradition.

But how do we hold them together?

Few writers today handle this balance better than Edward Feser, a philosophy professor and traditional Catholic thinker whose work I’ve followed and appreciated for years. In two recent articles —“A Catholic Defense of Enforcing Immigration Laws” and his follow-up, “Catholicism and Immigration: A Rejoinder to Cory and Sweeney”— Feser offers a deeply rooted, humane, and intellectually serious summary of the Catholic Church’s teaching on immigration. It’s a perspective worth hearing, especially for those who may assume that any restriction on immigration is incompatible with Christian love.

Order in Love: Why Family and Nation Matter

Feser’s starting point is an ancient and biblical idea: the ordo amoris, or the “order of love.” This principle, affirmed by St. Augustine and systematized by St. Thomas Aquinas, holds that while we are called to love all people, we are especially obligated to care first for those closest to us—our family, our neighbors, our nation.

As Aquinas puts it, “other things being equal, one ought to succor those rather who are most closely connected with us.” (Summa II-II.31.3)

This isn’t nationalism run amok—it’s common sense grounded in the reality of our created nature. We are not abstract global citizens first and foremost. We are embodied creatures born into specific families, places, and cultures. As Pope John Paul II argued, both family and nation are “natural societies” that shape and nurture us in essential ways. Patriotism—rightly ordered—isn’t idolatry. It’s a virtue connected to the Fourth Commandment: honoring your father and mother.

Welcoming the Stranger: A Real but Qualified Duty

Now, the Church is equally clear that we do have duties to the foreigner in need. The Catechism (2241) affirms that “the more prosperous nations are obliged, to the extent they are able, to welcome the foreigner in search of security and livelihood.”

But—and this is the part often overlooked—that obligation is not absolute. The same paragraph goes on to say that political authorities may “make the exercise of the right to immigrate subject to various juridical conditions,” especially with respect to the immigrant’s duty to obey the laws and respect the heritage of the host country.

Popes Benedict XVI and John Paul II both affirmed this prudential balance. The Church does not endorse “open borders.” Rather, it entrusts governments with the responsibility of weighing many legitimate concerns: economic stability, public safety, cultural cohesion, and social peace.

To quote Pope John Paul II: “Even highly developed countries are not always able to assimilate all those who emigrate….certainly, the exercise of such a right (to emigrate) is to be regulated, because practicing it indiscriminately may do harm and be detrimental to the common good of the community that receives the migrant.”

Prudence Is Not Relativism

Feser is careful to point out that recognizing a range of morally licit policy options is not relativism. Rather, it’s an application of the virtue of prudence—something Aquinas sees as essential to moral reasoning in complex situations. Christians of good will can, and often do, come to different conclusions about immigration policy while still honoring the same moral principles.

But what we can’t do is selectively quote the Church to support one side of the argument while ignoring the rest. Feser’s articles are a call to integrity—a plea to read the Church’s teaching in full, not just the parts that support our preferred politics.

The Forgotten Vice: Oikophobia

Feser also makes an important cultural observation. While Scripture rightly emphasizes love for the stranger—precisely because the default human temptation is tribal exclusion—our modern Western problem often cuts the other way. Many today (especially in elite circles) seem embarrassed by patriotism and suspicious of national loyalty. Philosopher Roger Scruton called this “oikophobia”—a fear or hatred of home. In our desire to care for others, we risk forgetting that we also have duties to our own.

This is not just a political point. It’s a theological one. Love must be ordered. We are to care for the poor and the outsider—but not in ways that undermine the health of the family, or the peace and stability of the nation. The ordo amoris demands both compassion and clarity.

A Word to My Progressive Friends

If you lean progressive and are reading this, I want to thank you for caring about the dignity of immigrants. That concern is a beautiful reflection of God’s heart. But I also want to invite you to consider Feser’s argument—not as a reactionary screed, but as a thoughtful, deeply Catholic appeal to moral coherence.

You may not agree with every policy endorsed by conservatives. I don’t either. But don’t let personality or partisanship keep you from considering the moral seriousness behind traditional immigration arguments.

I’m including links to both of Feser’s articles. I hope you’ll read them—not necessarily to be convinced, but at least to be more fully informed.

“The entirety of Church teaching—not only what it says about welcoming the stranger, but also what it says about the limitations on that obligation—must inform our judgments.”

— Edward Feser


LINKS TO READ:


+++