Compassion, Borders, and the Politics of Suspicion

A Response to a Friend About Immigration, Political Labels, and the Charity We Owe One Another.

A Conversation Between Friends

In a recent blog post, I examined America’s extraordinary record of immigration and raised questions about welfare participation, economic self-sufficiency, and the responsibilities of government.

A dear Christian friend responded thoughtfully, questioning some of the welfare statistics, expressing concerns about immigration enforcement, and acknowledging America’s remarkable generosity toward immigrants.

Fair enough. These are important questions, and we agreed on more than might initially appear.

But she also questioned my use of the word progressive to describe certain political positions. Might that term be pejorative? Perhaps even a “dog whistle”?

Well, that caught my attention. <grin>

Because beneath our disagreements about immigration lies another question, one that I think is increasingly important in our political and cultural life: How should Christians understand those with whom they disagree?

And when does legitimate criticism of someone’s political convictions become an unwarranted judgment about their character or hidden motivations?

Immigration, Welfare, and the Question of Accountability

Let’s begin with the welfare question.

In my previous post, I cited research from the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS), which analyzed Census Bureau data and found that 53% of immigrant-headed households received at least one major welfare benefit, compared with 37% of households headed by native-born Americans.

My friend pointed out that welfare participation doesn’t necessarily mean someone is unemployed or living on government checks.

Agreed. And I never suggested otherwise.

These are household statistics, not percentages of individual immigrants personally receiving benefits. Many recipients are working families struggling to make ends meet. Other researchers have found that immigrants consume fewer welfare and entitlement dollars per person than native-born Americans.

These findings aren’t necessarily contradictory. They’re measuring different things.

Here’s another important distinction. Under federal law, immigrants unlawfully present in the United States are generally ineligible for major federal welfare programs, including SNAP, regular Medicaid, and federal cash assistance. Important exceptions exist for emergency medical care, and certain services for children.

Furthermore, American-citizen children may lawfully receive benefits even when their parents are unlawfully present.

So when we discuss welfare participation by immigrant-headed households, we shouldn’t confuse those figures with the number of undocumented immigrants personally receiving public benefits.

But acknowledging these distinctions doesn’t make questions about immigration and public spending irrelevant.

Indeed, it raises another question: How effectively are we verifying eligibility, accounting for public expenditures, and ensuring that taxpayer dollars are spent according to the law?

Consider a recent controversy.

Beginning in 2025, the Trump administration requested detailed SNAP eligibility records from state governments to investigate improper payments, duplicate enrollments, and potential fraud.

According to the USDA’s May 2026 report, 29 state-level agencies and jurisdictions provided the requested records. More precisely, these were 28 states and Guam.

But 22 states and the District of Columbia were listed as not having provided the requested data:

Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Kansas, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Washington, and Wisconsin—along with the District of Columbia.

The USDA’s preliminary analysis of the submitted records identified approximately $3 billion annually in potentially improper payments arising from discrepancies that require further investigation.

That figure doesn’t mean $3 billion in fraud has been conclusively established. But surely it warrants serious scrutiny.

Several states have challenged the federal government’s requests in court, raising concerns about privacy, data security, and whether the demands exceed statutory authority. Federal judges have found legal problems with aspects of the requests and restricted the government’s ability to penalize states for refusing them.

But taxpayers have legitimate interests, too.

When states administer federally funded programs, shouldn’t the federal government have meaningful, legally authorized access to the information necessary to determine whether those programs are being administered properly?

And if most states can cooperate in providing the requested information, why have so many others resisted?

I strongly suspect political considerations are part of the explanation.

Congressional representation is apportioned according to a state’s total resident population, including people who are unlawfully present. Census population figures also influence the distribution of substantial federal funding.

That creates real political and fiscal incentives surrounding population growth and immigration policy. These incentives deserve honest public examination.  Will that happen?

And with our national debt now exceeding $40 trillion, fiscal accountability ought to concern every American, regardless of political affiliation.

What about immigration enforcement?

If government records establish that someone is receiving benefits for which they’re legally ineligible, those findings should be investigated and the law enforced. And I see no inherent moral objection to appropriate information-sharing with immigration authorities.

Privacy protections and accountability for public spending should not be mutually exclusive objectives.

Surely we can protect legitimate privacy interests while insisting that federal assistance programs be administered lawfully and transparently. 

QUESTION: Are we morally obliged to protect the privacy of an illegal alien?

The Good Samaritan and the Responsibilities of Government

Something frequently overlooked in these discussions is that American immigration law has long incorporated the principle of economic self-sufficiency.

Section 212(a)(4) of the Immigration and Nationality Act establishes what’s known as the public-charge provision. It makes prospective immigrants inadmissible if they’re determined likely to become public charges.

It states:

Any alien who … is likely at any time to become a public charge is inadmissible.

Congress has also established welfare eligibility restrictions for many immigrants and financial sponsorship requirements for certain immigration categories.

The underlying principle is unmistakable: America has long sought to balance its generosity toward immigrants with an expectation of economic self-sufficiency.

I believe that’s a sound principle.

Now, suppose an illegal immigrant suffers a terrible physical accident, e.g. car crash.  

Of course we should help. And we do! We provide that suffering person with the finest medical care in the history of humanity.

As Christians, the parable of the Good Samaritan reminds us that our responsibility toward a suffering neighbor doesn’t disappear because he belongs to another nation, ethnicity, or religious community.

But does that mean government has an unlimited obligation to admit illegal newcomers, regardless of its capacity to integrate them, provide services, or maintain public order?

NO! It does not.

There’s an important distinction between the Christian obligation to love our neighbor, the stranger, and the prudential responsibilities of civil government.

Governments must protect the vulnerable, including illegal immigrants, while enforcing laws, managing limited resources, and fulfilling their particular obligations to citizens. Those responsibilities sometimes require difficult choices.

My friend also expressed concerns about ICE enforcement practices, including racial profiling, family separation, and the removal of people without criminal convictions. 

QUESTION: If the vast majority of people crossing our border illegally are of Hispanic origin, should immigration authorities be prohibited from considering that demographic reality in their enforcement decisions? If the answer is yes, then it seems to me that “anti-racism” ideology is being weaponized to obstruct legitimate law enforcement. Of course, recognizing demographic patterns is not the same as treating someone’s ethnicity, by itself, as sufficient grounds for suspicion or detention. 

I agree that Immigration enforcement must be lawful, humane, and consistent with due process. Unnecessary cruelty should never be defended simply because an immigration law is being enforced.

But neither should we assume that removing someone who hasn’t committed an additional criminal offense is unjust. Unlawful presence and criminal convictions are different legal questions.

If immigration laws are to have meaning, they must ultimately be enforceable. Progressive policies tend not to recognize this distinction.  Why?

The question needs to be how to enforce immigration law justly while respecting human dignity.

Compassion and the rule of law are not enemies. A wise immigration policy should recognize both.

What’s Wrong with Calling Someone a Progressive?

Now, about that word progressive.

I try to use political identifiers that people actually choose for themselves.

My friend identifies as a progressive. I respect that. When I refer to the progressive Left, I’m identifying a recognizable political movement, not engaging in name-calling.

That doesn’t mean I believe its policies necessarily produce progress.

Quite the contrary.

I have serious disagreements with progressive economic theories, particularly those that place excessive confidence in government management or advocate forms of socialism.

But there’s something rather peculiar about our contemporary political vocabulary. 

Consider how casually words such as fascist and Nazi are hurled at political opponents on the Right. These terms carry enormous moral condemnation, and rightly so. Fascism and Nazism were responsible for some of the most horrific atrocities in human history.

Yet curiously, the words socialist and even communist lack anything approaching the same rhetorical sting. Indeed, some people proudly embrace those labels.

Why?

Surely it cannot be because socialism and communism have an unblemished historical record!

Consider what happened under Stalin in the Soviet Union, Mao in China, and Pol Pot in Cambodia. Political repression, mass executions, forced labor, engineered or catastrophically mismanaged famines, and the systematic destruction of individual liberty resulted in the deaths of tens of millions.

The Great Leap Forward under Mao alone produced a famine that historians estimate killed approximately 30 to 45 million people. And that’s only one episode in the history of twentieth-century communism.

The staggering scale of communist atrocities is beyond serious dispute.

None of this diminishes the unique horrors of the Holocaust or the monstrous crimes of National Socialism. Nor am I suggesting that someone advocating democratic socialism today necessarily endorses Stalinism or Maoism. (Although, despairingly, Maoism seems to be making a comeback in too many circles.)

But surely the historical record of these ideologies should command serious attention.

And this brings me to something I find particularly troubling about our educational institutions.

A 2026 Cato/YouGov survey found that 53% of Americans between 18 and 29 had a favorable view of socialism, while 38% viewed communism favorably.

Now, those findings don’t tell us precisely what younger Americans understand these terms to mean. Some undoubtedly associate socialism with Scandinavian social democracy rather than state ownership of the economy or revolutionary communism.

But isn’t that part of the problem?

How well do our younger generations understand the historical record of the Soviet Union, Maoist China, or Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge? How many could explain the Great Leap Forward, the Soviet Gulag system, or the catastrophic consequences of centrally planned economies?

And why do we seem to encounter such an enormous difference in the moral weight attached to the terms Nazi and communist?

I believe our educational system has a solemn responsibility to teach the history of both fascist and communist totalitarianism—their ideological foundations, their methods, their victims, and their consequences.

Where that history is neglected, minimized, or selectively presented, I consider it a serious dereliction of educational responsibility.

And I question whether all of this can be attributed simply to oversight.

In my earlier essay, When Truth Becomes a Servant of Activism, I raised concerns about what happens when scholarship and education become increasingly oriented toward ideological commitments and political activism rather than the disinterested pursuit of truth.

I believe that concern applies here as well.

When educational institutions approach history through preferred ideological frameworks, there’s an obvious temptation to emphasize the crimes of movements they oppose while minimizing or rationalizing the crimes of movements with which they sympathize.

I’m not suggesting that every educator is guilty of this. But I do believe ideological commitments are influencing what receives emphasis in our educational system—and what does not.

And when an entire generation can emerge with a well-developed moral revulsion toward Nazism but comparatively little understanding of the historical catastrophes associated with communism, we must ask some very uncomfortable questions.

Education should not teach students which historical atrocities to condemn according to contemporary political preferences. It should teach them the truth about all of them.

And that brings me back to my original point.

Political labels should be used accurately, not as weapons of moral intimidation. When someone identifies as a socialist or communist, we should take that identification seriously and examine what the person actually advocates. Likewise, we shouldn’t casually accuse people of being fascists or Nazis simply because we find their political convictions objectionable.

Historical literacy and intellectual honesty demand better.

And that brings me to the more interesting question raised by my friend’s response.

The Politics of Suspicion

My friend suggested that my use of the word progressive might function as a “dog whistle.”

Now, that’s an interesting expression.

In political discourse, a dog whistle refers to language that appears ordinary or innocent on the surface but supposedly communicates a hidden, often objectionable message to a particular audience.

Such coded language certainly exists.

But there’s a danger when we begin assuming that someone’s actual words conceal an entirely different meaning.

We risk moving from evaluating arguments into speculating about motivations.

And that can become a remarkably uncharitable habit.

There’s a philosophical tradition sometimes called the hermeneutics of suspicion, associated particularly with Karl Marx, Friedrich Nietzsche, and Sigmund Freud.

These thinkers differed considerably, but they shared a suspicion that people’s conscious explanations for their beliefs might conceal deeper forces—economic interests, psychological drives, desires for power, or ideological commitments.

Now, there’s certainly truth in the observation that human beings can misunderstand their own motivations.

As a Christian, I hardly need Marx or Freud to convince me of that!

Scripture repeatedly warns us about self-deception, pride, and the remarkable capacity of the human heart to rationalize its desires.

But recognizing that possibility is quite different from assuming we possess privileged insight into the hidden motivations of those with whom we disagree.

And I think this has become a troubling feature of contemporary political discourse.

A person argues for stricter immigration enforcement, and someone assumes the real motivation must be racial prejudice.

Someone opposes a progressive social policy, and the explanation supposedly lies in a subconscious desire to preserve structures of oppression.

The person’s stated reasons become almost irrelevant because the critic claims to understand what’s really going on beneath the surface.

But how can we meaningfully engage someone’s argument if we’ve already decided that the argument is merely a disguise for something morally objectionable?

Instead of asking whether a position is true, reasonable, or supported by evidence, we begin asking what hidden defect in the person might explain why he holds it.

Political disagreement becomes moral diagnosis.

That’s not an argument. It’s an accusation, even when dressed up in sophisticated philosophical language.

And this temptation certainly isn’t confined to the political Left.

Conservatives can be equally guilty of assuming that every progressive secretly despises America, wants socialism, or cares nothing about the rule of law.

That’s unfair, too.

Christians, of all people, ought to be especially careful about claiming knowledge of another person’s heart.

We can evaluate words, actions, policies, and their consequences. We can identify contradictions and challenge arguments vigorously.

But we should be much more cautious about presuming to know someone’s concealed intentions.

It’s a standard I believe we should all try to uphold.

Conclusion: Truth, Charity, and the Benefit of the Doubt

My friend and I disagree about some important political questions. I suspect we will continue to disagree.

That’s fine.

I don’t expect her to abandon her progressive convictions any more than she should expect me to abandon my conservative ones.

But surely we can agree on this: Intellectual honesty requires us to examine arguments seriously, while Christian charity requires us to resist assigning motives without sufficient evidence.

The Apostle Paul urges Christians to speak the truth in love (Ephesians 4:15).

Notice that he doesn’t ask us to choose between them.

Truth without love can become cruel. Love without truth can become sentimental and ultimately dishonest.

We need both.

So let’s challenge one another’s arguments. Let’s examine the evidence, question assumptions, and disagree vigorously when necessary.

But let’s also extend to one another the courtesy of being taken at our word unless there’s good reason to do otherwise.

Because the moment we decide that disagreement reveals some hidden moral defect in our neighbor, we’ve stopped listening to what that neighbor is actually saying.

And for Christians committed to loving both truth and neighbor, that simply won’t do.